The question was “This is a number written in French: 78,005. How would it be expressed in English? The reply was: 78.005. Am I gapping or was the question supposed to be “ This is a number written in English: 78,005. How would it be expressed in French?
Asked wrong?
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Terri,
The question and its answer are correct.
As it is specified that it is a number written in the French/European system, the ‘ virgule/ (decimal comma) ‘ is used to separate the ‘ whole number’ from the ‘ decimal fraction ‘. Hence the ‘ translation ‘ into the English/Imperial numerical system as ‘ 78.005 ‘ ( 78 decimal point 005 ).
It is an important point of the lesson that this significant difference exists between widespread European usage, and English-speaking countries in particular.
The ‘ virgule ‘ is never used in the ‘French’ system to separate hundreds from thousands, thousands from millions, millions from billions etc etc. In the French system these separations are usually just a clear space, but unfortunately sometimes a ‘ . ‘ leading to even more potential confusion to be aware of !
From the 3rd link below
“ Great Britain and the United States are two of the few places in the world that use a period to indicate the decimal place. Many other countries use a comma instead. The decimal separator is also called the radix character. Likewise, while the U.K. and U.S. use a comma to separate groups of thousands, many other countries use a period instead, and some countries separate thousands groups with a thin space. Table 1-3 shows some commonly used numeric formats. “
See links for more discussion on the significant differences :
https://quicksilvertranslate.com/252/numbers-decimal-comma-or-decimal-point2/#:~:text=The%20short%20answer%20is%2C%20English,exceptions%2C%20such%20as%20Mexican%20Spanish.
https://www.smartick.com/blog/other-contents/curiosities/decimal-separators/
https://docs.oracle.com/cd/E19455-01/806-0169/overview-9/index.html
I must have missed something in math because I still don’t get it.
This is a number written in French: "78,005". How would it be expressed in English?78,00578 00578,005.0078.005Terri,
try some other equivalent numbers
A) French/European system 78,5
is the same number as
English/American system 78.5
B) French/European system 78,05
is the same number as
English/American system 78.05
C ) French/ European 78,005
is the same number as
English/American 78.005
D) French/European 78,0005
is the same number as
English/American 78.0005
We don’t use decimal points in English we use commas. The only place we would use a decimal point is if it was something like 78,005.00. The French use decimal points or a space 78.005 or 78 005. When I go into the explanation on Kwiziq that is how they explain it as well so I think the question they are asking is backwards. It should read “This number written in English: 78,005” how would that be written in French? Which would be 78.005 or 78 005
Terri,
The number in the question written in the French system is not the number ‘ seventy-eight thousand ( and ) five ‘.
It is the number 78 followed by the fraction 5/1000 in decimal form - which is therefore written as 78,005 in the French system.
How do you write the number 78 followed by 5/1000 in decimal form in your part of the world ?
Do you use
a ‘ decimal comma ‘ between ‘ 78 ‘ and ‘ 005 ‘ giving ‘ 78,005 ‘ - as per the French system,
or
a ‘ decimal point ‘ between the ‘ 78 ‘ and the ‘ 005 ‘ - giving ‘ 78.005 ‘ - as per the English system ?
This is not really a French grammar issue - it is an international notation issue.
The French system never uses a ‘ decimal point ‘, only a ‘ decimal comma/virgule ‘, so anytime you see the virgule/comma in a French written number, it needs to be replaced by a ‘ decimal point ‘ if you want to interpret/rewrite the number using the English system.
It is worth reading the links I added previously , or search for others which discuss this and the other differences in detail.
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level