Stuart asked: "Could we not also say "une valeur sûre" as well as "une valeur certaine"? "

AurélieKwiziq language super star

Stuart asked: "Could we not also say "une valeur sûre" as well as "une valeur certaine"? "

Sa collection de tableaux a une ___ . (His painting collection has sure value.)
Asked 2 years ago
AurélieKwiziq language super starCorrect answer
Bonjour Stuart ! That's an interesting case! Indeed, "une valeur sûre" could seem to be a possible synonym here for "une valeur certaine", however they don't actually mean the same thing in French. ​ ​Look at this sentence: "Fais-moi confiance, c'est une valeur sûre !" (Trust me, it's a safe bet / a sure thing / a valued asset!) ​Note that you use it with "être", and would never say "avoir une valeur sûre". I hope that's helpful! À bientôt !
AurélieKwiziq language super starCorrect answer

Bonjour David !

I looked at the examples you provided and:

On a une valeur sûre avec Lisa Angeli.  
-> Here it's the same case I mentioned, where it means she is a reliable talent for these people. This sentence means that "they have a reliable winner in her."

As for the other examples, I must admit that they seem valid, though I've never used this expression like this myself.

I will therefore amend the question to accept both answers :)

Merci et bonne journée !

 

Hi Aurélie, That's a tricky point; I think most anglophones would use the two (certain , sure) interchangeably. You might consider integrating it in a quiz or placing a note in one of the lessons. Keep up the good work !

Here are examples of French speakers using "une valeur sûre" with avoir:

https://www.public.fr/Public-TV/Scoop-Public-TV/Exclu-Video-Stephane-Bern-Eurovision-2015-On-a-une-valeur-sure-avec-Lisa-Angell-730072

http://www.alterinfo.net/L-arnaque-de-la-recuperation-des-bijoux-en-or-par-des-operateurs-financiers-prives_a55634.html

(Comment #29)

https://vancouver.consulfrance.org/Notariat-et-legalisations-de-signature-Procedure

Stuart asked: "Could we not also say "une valeur sûre" as well as "une valeur certaine"? "

Sa collection de tableaux a une ___ . (His painting collection has sure value.)

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level >>
Ask a question
Let me take a look at that...