The answer to Joanne's question

Mabita P.B1Kwiziq community member

Hi Chris, Can you elaborate a little more on this please? "Oui, je les ai tous. -- Yes, I have them all. This makes no reference to any group of things of which you have taken some or all." I'm a little confused, why we can't say "J'en ai tous" but we say "J'en ai un". Thank you!

Asked 6 years ago

Like0Answer1

Chris W.C1Kwiziq Q&A super contributorCorrect answer

Hi Mabita,

The sentence "Yes, I have them all" references an implied group indirectly through the use of "all". All of what? That's the implied group.

Tu les as tous? -- Non, je n'en ai que trois. -- Do you have all of them? No, I have only three (of them).

Like06 years ago

Mabita P. asked:

The answer to Joanne's question

Hi Chris, Can you elaborate a little more on this please? "Oui, je les ai tous. -- Yes, I have them all. This makes no reference to any group of things of which you have taken some or all." I'm a little confused, why we can't say "J'en ai tous" but we say "J'en ai un". Thank you!

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today