Are Le + Y interchangeable when using à?

Natalie B.A2KwizIQ community member

Are Le + Y interchangeable when using à?

Tu veux venir à la piscine? - Oui, je le veux

Does this mean that y and le are interchangeable when à is used as a preposition? Obviously meaning is slightly changed but would the different meaning make a huge problem?

e.g. je le veux vs je veux y venir


Asked 6 years ago
Cécile J.A1KwizIQ Q&A super contributorCorrect answer

Hi Nathalie,

No, they mean different things.

When you answer -

Je le veux 

it means:

yes, I do  ( simply you agree to go swimming)

If you answered,

Je veux y aller, it would mean:

yes, I want to go there, probably meaning the swimming pool.

Hope this helps!

 

Valerie O.C1KwizIQ Q&A regular contributor

May I ask something further about this specific question/answer? The lesson states that "y" is used if the phrase starts with "a" (sorry, can't get the accent to work). So I really don't understand why the answer is je le veux. Unless...is it because the phrase is preceded by an infinitive (eg, venir)? Thanks.

Cécile J.A1KwizIQ Q&A super contributor

Hi Valerie, 

Je le veux 

is more'

I want to (go) 

rather than 

Je veux y aller = I want to go there ( there being the swimming pool)

Natalie B. asked:

Are Le + Y interchangeable when using à?

Tu veux venir à la piscine? - Oui, je le veux

Does this mean that y and le are interchangeable when à is used as a preposition? Obviously meaning is slightly changed but would the different meaning make a huge problem?

e.g. je le veux vs je veux y venir


Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your French level
Getting that for you now...