Answered! Jump to accepted answer.
Kwiziq community member
7 April 2018
B2 writing challenge re. a relative pronoun used
Once again, (toujours!) I chose the wrong relative pronoun. I wrote "ce que" in the B2 writing challenge, as I thought "that" referred to the fact that it snowed last night (a whole idea, not just a noun). The correct answer was "que". Below, is the correct sentence from the exercise:
Il a tellement neigé la nuit dernière (it snowed so much last night)
que le jardin était (re)couvert d’un épais manteau blanc (that the garden was convered with a thick white coat)
Can someone please explain why que is the correct answer in this sentence, instead of ce que?
8 April 2018
in the sentence you quote, "que" is not a relative pronoun at all. Rather, it is a conjunction. To see the difference, ask yourself the question what (if anything) "que" refers to.
l a tellement neigé la nuit dernière, que le jardin était couvert d’un épais manteau blanc.It snowed so much last nicht, that the garden was covered by a tick, white coat.
A telltale sign that you are NOT dealing with a relative pronoun is to try and replace "that" by "which". If it doesn't work at all, you have yourself a conjunction. Here are some examples of either:
J'aime ce que tu as fait. -- I like what you did."ce que" is a relative pronoun relating to the idea (not mentioned per se) of what the other person did.
J'aime que tu sois venu. -- I like that you came.This time "que" is a conjunction and NOT a relative pronoun.
Les lunettes, que j'ai perdues, sont dans ma chambre. -- The glasses that (which) I lost, are in my room.This time "que" is a relative pronoun because it clearly refers back to "les lunettes".
I hope that helps, -- Chris (not a native speaker).
Once again, thanks for the rescue Chris!
I must admit that I've not yet made a study of French conjunctions, & after all the reading I've done about relative pronouns, I guess I've just got locked into thinking of "que" as one of those! Your reply has enlightened me, especially that if I substitute "which" & it doesn't work, I'll know to use "que" (conjunction), - that will be my guiding rule for now.
Kwiziq language super star
15 April 2018
If I can just add to what Chris has just said. In the example you give you need 'que' because of the 'tellement' earlier in the sentence .
The expression is 'tellement...que' meaning, so much... that .
e.g. J'ai mangé tellement de chocolat que je suis malade.
Hope this helps!
and thank you for your input. I appreciate reading this additional point.
My current study efforts in French are relative pronouns and conjunctions. I'm finding it difficult to choose the correct relative pronoun in the writing challenges: que (or) ce que. I often write the incorrect one. The "hints" given in the writing challenge, (frequently: "which"), don't ensure that I choose the correct "que".. unfortunately.
Login to submit your answer
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Test your French to the CEFR standard
French listening practice
French reading practice
French speaking practice
French writing practice