La Dune du Pilat Grammar question and size of Dune ?

N. Hilary (Shamrockhill) W.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

La Dune du Pilat Grammar question and size of Dune ?

Thank you for this fun exercise. I had never heard of the Dune du Pilat. I looked it up and it is beautiful!

Grammar Question: 

In the sentence:

"Comme son nom l'indique, c'est une immense dune de sable", where is the grammar lesson for using the pronoun " l' " in this case? The two pronoun lessons listed don't address this particular usage of the pronoun. Since there isn't a previous idea stated, what does the 'l' refer to?  I seem to remember a lesson about this, but couldn't find it in the library. Would it be correct to say, "Comme son nom indique, c'est une immense dune de sable."?

Also, when I read, "Elle mesure environ 102 metres !", I was thinking of the length not the height.

Maybe the phrase could be amended to say, "Elle mesure 102 metres de hauteur." ?

Just for fun, here are the entire measurements from the Wikipedia page:

"The dune has a volume of about 60,000,000 m³, measuring around 500 m wide from east to west and 2.7 km in length from north to south (1.35 km2).[2][3] Its height was 106.60 m above sea level as of 2018."

Merci beaucoup !


Asked 2 years ago
Maarten K.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

I can confirm La Dune du Pilat is most impressive - have climbed it but not yet walked its full length, as I was too busy taking photos while my brother-in-law did the full walk. It has been off limits during the recent ‘canicule’ but hopefully will be open again in October, when I hope to “conquer” it fully.  

‘Indiquer’ is transitive - the object pronoun is required in this construction. 

Son nom indique que c’est une immense dune de sable ? Oui, son nom l’indique.  

In the transcript, the ‘previously mentioned idea’ follows immediately in the same sentence - so it is still known to the reader/listener what the object pronoun refers to. (Effectively, the sentence is inverted ‘C’est une immense dune de sable, comme son nom l’indique’.) 

https://dictionnaire.lerobert.com/definition/indiquer 

Using le/la/l'/les = it/him/her/them (French Direct Object Pronouns) 

Using neuter pronouns le or l' to refer to previously mentioned ideas (French Direct Object Pronouns)

N. Hilary (Shamrockhill) W. asked:

La Dune du Pilat Grammar question and size of Dune ?

Thank you for this fun exercise. I had never heard of the Dune du Pilat. I looked it up and it is beautiful!

Grammar Question: 

In the sentence:

"Comme son nom l'indique, c'est une immense dune de sable", where is the grammar lesson for using the pronoun " l' " in this case? The two pronoun lessons listed don't address this particular usage of the pronoun. Since there isn't a previous idea stated, what does the 'l' refer to?  I seem to remember a lesson about this, but couldn't find it in the library. Would it be correct to say, "Comme son nom indique, c'est une immense dune de sable."?

Also, when I read, "Elle mesure environ 102 metres !", I was thinking of the length not the height.

Maybe the phrase could be amended to say, "Elle mesure 102 metres de hauteur." ?

Just for fun, here are the entire measurements from the Wikipedia page:

"The dune has a volume of about 60,000,000 m³, measuring around 500 m wide from east to west and 2.7 km in length from north to south (1.35 km2).[2][3] Its height was 106.60 m above sea level as of 2018."

Merci beaucoup !


Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Let me take a look at that...