"C'est alors que Maxine_______mon sac et s'est enfin en courant." I got this question wrong because I chose the Imparfait rather than PC. Is the correct reason for using the PC because Marie's action is best described as a sudden one, it cuts into something ongoing? I thought I had the difference between the two straight in my mind but obviously "non". Can you explain/confirm if my reasoning (after getting it wrong!) is correct? Thanks. Valerie
In future, these type of queries, if from a quiz, you should use the Report It button on your correction board as it will link directly to the quiz and is easier for us to answer you.
I will try and answer this one but the French doesn't make much sense.
Is it -
Maxine a pris /a coupé son sac et s'est enfuie en courant ?
Maxine took/cut her bag and fled running
If that's the case these two brief actions are consecutive and the perfect tense is correct.
I think I remember seeing this question in the quizzes too - it is I believe 's'est enfuie' - fled or ran away ('en courant' is tautological here) . However, with that noted, the sentence does indeed mean something like "That is when (or - it is then that) Maxine cut my bag and ran away (fled running)" - yes, it will be passé composé (Maxine a coupé mon sac) as the action of cutting was a single, defined and completed action.
Thank you both! Makes better sense now.
Sign in to submit your answer
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Test your French to the CEFR standard