Mal à vs mal

Kevin S.A1KwizIQ community member

Mal à vs mal

In the lesson I don’t see the rule for when to use mal without the à What is it please ?
Asked 1 year ago
CélineKwizIQ Native French TeacherCorrect answer

Bonjour Kevin,

The lesson is about "faire mal à quelqu'un" versus "faire du mal à quelqu'un". As you can see the expression from the lesson always includes [to someone/à quelqu'un].

You can have the expression "faire mal" on its own in French:

Une piqûre peut faire malAn injection can hurt
La piqûre d'une guêpe fait mal = The sting of a wasp hurts

EDIT:

The à "disappears" when the person hurt is replaced by an indirect object pronoun (me, te, lui, nous, vous, leur) placed before the verb and that pronoun already means "à + person":

Elle me fait du mal = She hurts me -> à moi / me

Il va lui faire du mal = He is going to hurst her/him -> à elle/lui / her/him

Tu leur as fait du mal = You hurt them -> à euxthem

Take a look here for more: faire mal

I hope this is helpful.

Bonne journée !

Jennifer C.A2KwizIQ community member

I’m afraid your response did not clarify Kevin S’s query for me.

The lesson states: 

To express to hurt someone (emotionally), you use the expression faire du mal à + person. Examples:

·      Il va faire du mal à ma meilleure amie. He's going to hurt my best friend.  (emotionally)

·      Tu as fait du mal à Paula quand tu as rompu avec elle.  You hurt Paula when you broke up with her.

Yet, later in the lesson the examples drop the à for emotional hurt:

·      Elle me fait du mal quand elle dit ça. She hurts me when she says that.

What is the rule is for including / excluding the  à when referring to emotional hurt ?

CélineKwizIQ Native French Teacher

Bonjour Jennifer,

Youre right! I missed something in my first response.

I have now updated it ! See the EDIT part ;-)

Merci de votre contribution !

Bonne journée !

Kevin S. asked:

Mal à vs mal

In the lesson I don’t see the rule for when to use mal without the à What is it please ?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your French level
I'll be right with you...