Louise a souffert? Je pensais que les sentiments, les émotions et l'action continue seraient l'imparfait?
Temps du verbe suffrir
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Bonjour Helen,
Great question!
'Elle a souffert tout au long de sa vie' uses passé composé because:
It views the suffering as a complete whole -
You're looking back at her entire life as a finished period. The phrase 'tout au long de sa vie' frames her life as a completed timeframe, and you're making a statement about that entire period. You're stating that this suffering happened, viewing it as an accomplished fact.
If you zoomed in on a period of her life, however, you could use imparfait in contexts like:
Elle souffrait beaucoup à cette époque = She was suffering a lot during that time (ongoing state)
Quand je la connaissais, elle souffrait = When I knew her, she was suffering (descriptive background)
The key is that 'tout au long de sa vie' treats her life as a completed unit of time, which naturally calls for passé composé
Hope this helps!
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level